Borrowing costs for 350m Europeans may hinge on a deal between Berlin and Paris. Germany backs a Spaniard to lead the European Central Bank and claims the chief economist post for itself. France wants a seat too. Critics warn that national bargaining is crowding out merit.

After European Central Bank (ECB) President Christine Lagarde announced her resignation in late October, European capitals quickly began manoeuvring to secure influence over the selection of her successor. With three of the ECB’s six Executive Board members due to leave in 2027, the negotiations extend beyond Ms Lagarde’s succession to a broader reshuffle of the bank’s top leadership.

Now, three weeks later, a deal is emerging. It would see a Spaniard lead the institution with German support, while Berlin takes the influential chief economist post. France, meanwhile, looks set to keep a seat on the bank’s Executive Board. The negotiations highlight how national interests can shape the leadership of one of Europe’s most powerful financial institutions.

Horse-trading over Frankfurt’s top jobs

The race to succeed Ms Lagarde has centred on two candidates. One is Spain’s Pablo Hernández de Cos, who now heads the Bank for International Settlements. He is a former Bank of Spain governor and an ally of former ECB President Mario Draghi. The other is Klaas Knot, who led the Dutch central bank until 2025.

You might be interested

Mr Hernández de Cos has emerged as the frontrunner after Germany signalled its support for his candidacy. In return, Berlin is seeking the ECB’s chief economist position for Princeton University professor Markus Brunnermeier.

According to Reuters, Berlin’s strategy could help secure the Spanish candidate’s appointment by maintaining a balance between northern and southern European representation on the ECB’s six-member Executive Board. At the same time, landing the chief economist position would give a German national a key role in shaping the bank’s monetary policy proposals.

The German cabinet approved Mr Brunnermeier’s nomination on 18 November, although the appointment itself remains subject to the EU selection process. Germany’s backing of Mr Hernández de Cos also complicates the prospects of Mr Knot, whose appointment alongside a German chief economist could concentrate two influential positions in northern Europe.

Such geographical considerations reflect longstanding differences between northern and southern eurozone countries. Many southern governments carry heavier public debts. They have generally favoured lower interest rates and greater financial risk-sharing. The north has traditionally taken a more cautious approach.

Paris eyes a key ECB role

France stands to take a seat on the Executive Board when board member Isabel Schnabel steps down in early January. Paris may seek to take over her market operations portfolio, economists told Reuters. It includes responsibility for the ECB’s bond-buying programmes, a sensitive matter amid tensions in France’s debt market.

Reports have named former OECD chief economist Laurence Boone and Banque de France deputy governor Agnès Bénassy-Quéré as potential candidates. On 17 November, Le Monde reported that a Franco-German agreement was emerging. Under it, Ms Boone could take over the portfolio, with Mr Hernández de Cos as president and Mr Brunnermeier as chief economist.

Such negotiations reflect longstanding informal conventions favouring representation from the eurozone’s largest economies, particularly Germany, France, and Italy. Eurogroup President Kyriakos Pierrakakis also acknowledged the political dimension of ECB appointments. He described the selection as “a political and consensus driven process” ahead of a meeting on 9 November.

Expertise or national interests?

Yet while governments negotiate the balance of power, the formal requirements for joining the ECB’s Executive Board remain relatively broad. Under EU rules, candidates must be nationals of eurozone countries and have “recognised standing and professional experience in monetary or banking matters”.

Eurozone governments nominate candidates. The Eurogroup discusses them before the Council of the EU makes a recommendation. The European Council then makes the final appointment after consulting the European Parliament and the ECB’s Governing Council, neither of which has veto power.

In an analysis for the Brussels-based think tank Bruegel, visiting fellow Andreas Billmeier raises doubts about whether the process places enough emphasis on expertise. Although the Governing Council has never objected to a nominee, its assessments focus on whether candidates meet the minimum legal requirements rather than whether they are best suited to the ECB’s needs.

Mr Billmeier also warns that a selection process shaped largely by central bankers may favour familiar professional backgrounds. Yet the ECB’s responsibilities keep expanding, from banking supervision and financial stability to the development of a digital euro.

To address these shortcomings, Mr Billmeier proposes publishing specific professional profiles for vacant positions and establishing an independent advisory panel to assess candidates’ qualifications and independence. Governments would retain the final say but would have to justify publicly any decisions that go against the panel’s recommendations.

Similar selection panels already exist for appointments to the EU’s highest courts and the European Public Prosecutor’s Office. Mr Billmeier argues that such a reform would not require changes to EU treaties.

With Executive Board members serving non-renewable eight-year terms, the stakes extend far beyond the current negotiations. The ECB already assesses the suitability of executives at the banks it supervises. Applying similar standards to its own leadership could help ensure that professional merit carries as much weight as national interests in deciding who leads the bank, Mr Billmeier argues.

Through crisis after crisis

Ms Lagarde will step down on 7 February, nearly nine months before her term was due to end. Since taking office in November 2019, she has guided the bank’s monetary policy through the Covid-19 pandemic, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and a series of energy shocks. Her successor will inherit an institution confronting renewed inflationary pressures, weak economic growth, and concerns over public debt in parts of the eurozone.

I don’t think that I can remain neutral. I don’t think that I can be comfortable in that neutrality at the present time. — Christine Lagarde, European Central Bank President

Explaining her decision, the ECB president said she wanted greater freedom to speak about issues beyond monetary policy, as her position required political neutrality. “I don’t think that I can remain neutral. I don’t think that I can be comfortable in that neutrality at the present time,” she said at the 29 October press conference. Her departure comes ahead of France’s presidential election next spring, raising questions about the political implications of her decision.